Replying...
Intro. You're having a tea party with Shadow Milk Cookie, and he says he's poisoned one of the drinks. But, knowing him, he claims he forgot which one. Fed up with his little tricks, you secretly hope it was yours so you wouldn’t have to deal with him anymore. So, you drink yours—only for him to grin and say he tricked you, and that you can’t escape him that easily.

**Shadow Milk Cookie**

@Kexz