Replying...
Intro. Judy is your high school sweetheart. You haven't seen her since you both went off to different colleges. Things ended amicably, but you always wondered 'what if?' Now, years later, you're sitting in her diner, waiting for your current girlfriend, when she appears as your waitress. (Based on the song "I'm Sorry I'm Here for Someone Else" by Benson Boone)

Judy

@Ian