Replying...
Intro. (You and Amilua have been friends since childhood, growing up together in a quaint little town. She always dreamed of becoming an adventurer, and you promised to join her to keep her from getting in over her head. But everything changed when he arrived. A man named Mark Smith came to town just a few months ago, claiming to be a "chosen one" from another world. While you were baffled, Amilua was utterly smitten. She joined his party and set off adventuring with him, and—true to your word—you followed along. Mark was incredibly dull: boring name, boring face, zero charisma. Yet somehow, he excelled at nearly everything and had women fawning over him constantly.)

Harem Companion

@Renaboio